ヒューマノイドロボットシミュレータの定量的比較
A Comparison of Humanoid Robot Simulators: A Quantitative Approach
Gazebo・Webots・V-REPの3つのシミュレータでNAOロボットの障害物回避ナビゲーションを各20回実行し、CPU・メモリ・ディスク使用量を比較した。Webotsが最もリソース消費が少なく、次いでV-REP、Gazeboの順であった。
著者: Angel Ayala, Francisco Cruz, Diego Campos, Rodrigo Rubio, Bruno Fernandes, Richard Dazeley
分類: cs.RO
原文アブストラクト
Research on humanoid robotic systems involves a considerable amount of computational resources, not only for the involved design but also for its development and subsequent implementation. For robotic systems to be implemented in real-world scenarios, in several situations, it is preferred to develop and test them under controlled environments in order to reduce the risk of errors and unexpected behavior. In this regard, a more accessible and efficient alternative is to implement the environment using robotic simulation tools. This paper presents a quantitative comparison of Gazebo, Webots, and V-REP, three simulators widely used by the research community to develop robotic systems. To compare the performance of these three simulators, elements such as CPU, memory footprint, and disk access are used to measure and compare them to each other. In order to measure the use of resources, each simulator executes 20 times a robotic scenario composed by a NAO robot that must navigate to a goal position avoiding a specific obstacle. In general terms, our results show that Webots is the simulator with the lowest use of resources, followed by V-REP, which has advantages over Gazebo, mainly because of the CPU use.
関連論文
- 詳細メッシュ対応の接触リッチ相互作用向け軽量シミュレータLodosシミュレーション
- Ostrich: 微分可能ダイナミクスにおける剛直な接触を跨ぐ大きな歩幅シミュレーション
- Agri-Sim: 温室ロボティクスにおける具現化知能評価のための農業シミュレーションプラットフォームシミュレーション
- 浅海域の写実性を超えて:深海ロボティクスのための物理・センサ接地シミュレーションシミュレーション
- NVIDIA Cosmos-H-Dreams: 手術ロボットのためのリアルタイム生成物理シミュレーションシミュレーション
- CRESSim-Neo: 手術ロボティクスとロボット学習のためのバッチ処理GPUシミュレーションエンジンシミュレーション
