快適性重視の運転:人間ドライバーと動作計画アルゴリズムの性能比較
Comfort-oriented driving: performance comparison between human drivers and motion planners
公道実験で人間ドライバーの運転データを計測し、最適化ベースの動作計画アルゴリズムと快適性・時間効率のバランスを比較した。
著者: Yanggu Zheng, Barys Shyrokau, Tamas Keviczky
分類: cs.RO, cs.SY, eess.SY
原文アブストラクト
Motion planning is a fundamental component in automated vehicles. It influences the comfort and time efficiency of the ride. Despite a vast collection of studies working towards improving motion comfort in self-driving cars, little attention has been paid to the performance of human drivers as a baseline. In this paper, we present an experimental study conducted on a public road using an instrumented vehicle to investigate how human drivers balance comfort and time efficiency. The human driving data is compared with two optimization-based motion planners that we developed in the past. In situations when there is no difference in travel times, human drivers incurred an average of 23.5% more energy in the longitudinal and lateral acceleration signals than the motion planner that minimizes accelerations. In terms of frequency-weighted acceleration energy, an indicator correlated with the incidence of motion sickness, the average performance deficiency rises to 70.2%. Frequency-domain analysis reveals that human drivers exhibit more longitudinal oscillations in the frequency range of 0.2-1 Hz and more lateral oscillations in the frequency range of up to 0.2 Hz. This is reflected in time-domain data features such as less smooth speed profiles and higher velocities for long turns. The performance difference also partly results from several practical matters and additional factors considered by human drivers when planning and controlling vehicle motion. The driving data collected in this study provides a performance baseline for motion planning algorithms to compare with and can be further exploited to deepen the understanding of human drivers.
関連論文
- 学習された軌道プリミティブと確率的安全性評価を用いたリスク認識型動作計画自動運転/動作計画
- 分岐確率モデル予測制御によるマルチモーダル不確実性下の動作計画:シナリオクラスタリングを用いた手法自動運転/動作計画
- MORPH-U: 高不確実環境下でのV2X対応自動運転のための多目的レジリエント動作計画とシミュレーション評価自動運転/動作計画
- MISTY: ミキサーベース単一ステップドリフトによる高スループット動作計画自動運転/動作計画
- 閉ループ自動運転における拡散ベース動作計画のためのオープンソースモジュラーベンチマーク自動運転/動作計画
- PIE: 自動運転のための知覚・インタラクション強化型エンドツーエンド動作計画自動運転/動作計画
